3-Star Pet Food Reviews
287 reviews
Pet foods that earned a 3-star verdict in our label-based reviews — the middle of the range. These recipes are balanced enough for everyday feeding but make clearer trade-offs, such as more generic ingredient naming or a lower share of animal protein. Worth weighing against higher-rated options before you decide.
Browse by star rating
Browse by Hide
Browse by food type
Browse by dietary
Browse by protein level
Browse by fat level
Browse by protein quality
Browse by protein clarity
-
Buddy Bites Fresh Chicken Recipe Adult Cat Food
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Unknown product
Dry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Natural Greatness Sensitive Indoor Adult Cat - All Breed
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Hill's Science Diet Kitten Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Supplements Hydra Care
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
TOPRATION Grow-up Kitty
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Oven-Baked Tradition Grain Free Red Meat
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Hero Mama HERO Glowing Freeze-Dried Meal
CatFreeze-Dried★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Wellness Healthy Indulgence Shreds with Chicken and Turkey
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
ecare Adult Cat Food Chicken Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Wellness CORE+ Indoor Adult Deboned Chicken, Turkey Meal & Chicken Meal Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Wellness CORE+ Indoor Salmon & Herring Meal Recipe Adult
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Tiger by ASDA Pockets with Salmon
Cat★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
AIME Kitchen Pacific Hake Cat Food
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Unknown product
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
心凍糧 Low-Grain Dog Food (Chicken Recipe)
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Leonardo Fresh Salmon
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Boreal Boreal Health Formula Wild Salmon
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
AIME Kitchen Wild Salmon Cat Food
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
MonPetit Fine Cut Dual Main Meal Can Variety Pack
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Meadow Land Ngeru Salmon Complete & Balanced Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
TRILOGY Adult Prime Maintenance Complete Prey Chicken + Freeze Dried Lamb
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
INDIGO Age Nutrition Adult for Cat
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Bella & Molly's Golden Goat Series Tender Tuna Smooth Mousse
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
1st Choice Nutrition Adult Healthy Skin & Coat Salmon Formula
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Oven-Baked Tradition Grain-Free Chicken Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
PROUDPET Weight Management Formula
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
PetKind Venison Tripe Formula
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Addiction Viva La Venison Entree Grain-Free
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Indigo Bio Nutrition Gut Health For Kitten
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Grandma Mae's Country Naturals Grain Free Dog Food Turkey Meal Recipe
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Hill's Science Diet Tender Ocean Fish Dinner Adult 1-6
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Addiction Salmon Bleu Grain-Free
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Oven-Baked Tradition Grain-Free Duck Small Breed All Life Stages
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Keptbaby Free-Range Chicken - Immune Health
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Keptbaby Wandering Rabbit - Oral Health
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
沙發馬鈴薯 Keptbaby吃軟飯主食餐包-小寶鮮嫩
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Unknown product
Dry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Forest Classic
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Sauzy Monoprotein Veal
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain Feline Recipe with Roasted Venison & Smoked Salmon
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Taste of the Wild PREY Angus Beef Formula for Cats
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Gosbi Natsbi Steamed Chicken
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Pet Select Chicken in Gravy
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Now Fresh Grain-Free Recipe with Trout, Salmon & Herring Adult Cat
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Stella & Chewy's Freeze-Dried Raw Coated Kibble Wild-Caught Salmon Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Hill's Science Diet Adult 7+ Chicken Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
1st Choice Nutrition Adult Indoor Vitality Chicken Formula
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Hill's Science Diet Indoor Adult 1-6 Chicken Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Wellness CORE+ Indoor Deboned Chicken, Turkey Meal & Chicken Meal Recipe Adult
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
CRIUS Grain Free Turkey Recipe with Air Dried Chicken
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Hill's Science Diet Tender Chicken Dinner Adult 1-6
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Vigor & Sage Ginseng Well-Being Fresh Chicken & Seaweed Adult Cat
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
nutrientBoost Chicken Recipe Small Breed Dog Food
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Vigor & Sage Astragalus Well-Being Fresh Turkey & Seaweed Mono Animal Protein
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Fat Dogs Adult Dog Healthy Weight Weight Control Formula
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
GO! Solutions Sensitivities Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Venison Recipe
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Dr.Wish Chicken+Tuna+Taurine
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Vitapet Tuna
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Bungener Kitten Essence Milk
Cat★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5