3-Star Pet Food Reviews
228 reviews
Pet foods that earned a 3-star verdict in our label-based reviews — the middle of the range. These recipes are balanced enough for everyday feeding but make clearer trade-offs, such as more generic ingredient naming or a lower share of animal protein. Worth weighing against higher-rated options before you decide.
Browse by star rating
Browse by Hide
Browse by food type
Browse by dietary
Browse by protein level
Browse by fat level
Browse by protein quality
Browse by protein clarity
-
Now Fresh Grain-Free Recipe with Turkey, Salmon & Duck Adult Cat
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Blue Buffalo Wild Spirit with Deboned Chicken Indoor Adult Cat
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Healthy Paws Canine Complete Raw Dog Food – Beef
DogRaw★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Beast Paradise Dragon Tiger Grouper Main Meal Pouch
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Petcurean GO! Solutions Sensitivities Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Salmon Recipe
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Naturca Acqua Deep Ocean Tuna
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
SHOGUN Japanese Venison Mixed Whole Grains
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Unknown product
Dry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
FirstMate Pacific Ocean Fish Meal Weight Control Formula
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
VIIM Baked Cat Food - Baked Chicken with Freeze Dried Chicken
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
小安心 成猫期全价冻干双拼猫粮
CatFreeze-Dried★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Salican Pet Food with Lamb in Gravy
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Friskies Friskies Shreds With Beef In Gravy Wet Cat Food
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Friskies Shreds Turkey & Cheese Dinner In Gravy Wet Cat Food
CatWet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Ambrosia Grain Free Fresh Meat Dog Food (Turkey & Duck)
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Taste of the Wild Pacific Salmon Seafood (Adult Grain-Free)
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Canagan Scottish Salmon For Cats
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Herz Air-Dried Venison with Duck Liver
DogAir-Dried★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Pro's Choice Picky Dog Palatability Formula (Functional Health Care Series)
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Coter Sensitive
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Grandma Mae's Country Naturals Small Breed Grain Free Lamb Meal Recipe
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Kaniva Chicken, Tuna & Rice
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Canagan Insect Protein
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Pure & Natural (伯纳天纯) Complete Small Breed Adult Dog Food
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Myfoodie Shuran SUPER Coat+ Fish Oil Cat Food (Chicken)
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Schesir Kitten Rich in Chicken
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Nutrience SubZero Turkey & Pumpkin Recipe Limited Ingredients
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
HOXY FRESH Grain-Free Adult Cat Formula
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Pro Plan Adult Indoor Hairball Control
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Hero Mama Hero Glowing Freeze-Dried Meal Chicken Recipe
CatFreeze-Dried★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Unknown product
Wet★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Unknown product
Dry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Simply Light Or Senior
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Nutrience SubZero Duck & Pear Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Eden White Fish with Herring Caviar
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Petcurean Go! Solutions Skin + Coat Care Grain-Free Salmon Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Fussie Cat Market Fresh Salmon & Chicken Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Pro Plan Advantage Digestive Support+ Salmon & Oat Meal Formula Dog Food
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Annamaet Grain Free Feline Sustain No. 29 Sustainable Fish Formula
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Petcurean Go! Solutions Sensitivities Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Duck Recipe
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Giggle's Bites Buddy Bites Adult Sweet Potato & Salmon Recipe
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Hero Mama HERO Glowing Freeze-Dried Meal
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Purina Pro Plan Adult LiveClear
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Big Dog Pet Foods Chicken
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5 -
Addiction Salmon Bleu
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
AVP Grain-Free Cat Food Chicken with Salmon & Tuna
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Trilogy Complete Prey Kibble Australian Salmon
DogDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.0 -
Trilagy Adult Complete Prey Chicken + Freeze Dried Lamb
CatDry★︎★︎★︎☆︎☆︎ 3.5